Psychiatry’s Trek Through Madness, A Book Review of Shrinks: The Untold Story of Psychiatry

Zachary Friedrich

The development of nearly all modern medical specialties has followed the same pattern of gradual advancement with the occasional breakthrough discovery. However, psychiatry’s history has been one of “false starts, extended periods of stagnation, and two steps forward and one step back” (Shrinks 11). Jeffrey A. Lieberman, former president of the American Psychiatric Association, wrote Shrinks: The Untold Story of Psychiatry with a purpose in mind: “to provide an honest chronicle of psychiatry with all its rogues and charlatans, its queasy treatments and ludicrous theories” (10). By doing so, Lieberman, with the help of theoretical neuroscientist and talented writer Ogi J. Ogas, sets out to redeem psychiatry from its dark past and dispel the pervasive stigma surrounding it today. Does Shrinks have the potential to usher in a new era of psychiatry and change the hearts of millions of Americans that hesitate to accept psychiatry as a legitimate medical specialty?

psych1

Shrinks takes its readers through the history of psychiatry, which arguably began in the 1770s with Franz Anton Mesmer, whom some consider to be the first psychiatrist. Mesmer postulated that one’s flow of a special invisible energy called animal magnetism determined one’s mental health and believed people could only be cured of their mental illnesses through contact with a conductor of animal magnetism like himself (Shrinks 28). Mesmer and his contemporaries proposed many far-fetched theories that would go on to be proved false.

A practitioner of mesmerism using animal magnetism on a woman who responds with convulsions

A practitioner of mesmerism using animal magnetism on a woman who responds with convulsions

The failed attempts of early psychiatrists was not the only factor contributing to the dark past of psychiatry. Until the mid-1900s, the mentally ill were kept in asylums and other institutions separate from hospitals where all other medical specialties operated. The rate of recovery for the severely mentally ill was extraordinarily low and psychiatrists functioned more as compassionate caretakers rather than actual doctors that could cure their patients. Psychiatrists of this era developed controversial and often dangerous treatments (Shrinks 36). Lieberman tells the story of Julius Wagner-Jauregg, who developed pyrotherapy as a treatment for syphilis-induced “general paresis of the insane” (156, 157). The procedure involved purposefully infecting the patient with malaria to induce a high fever. It was often successful and the patient’s psychosis would disappear, but this was only because the malaria-induced fever would cause the syphilis parasite to die (Shrinks 158). However, fifteen percent of the patients that received this Nobel Prize-winning psychiatric treatment died from the procedure (Shrinks 157). Lieberman goes on to candidly describe other obsolete treatments such as lobotomies and insulin-induced comas, not shying away from the controversial practices that earned psychiatry the stigma it no longer deserves.

1934 photograph of malarial transfusion from one patient to a neurosyphilitic patient.  Dr. Wagner-Jauregg is in a suit on the right.

1934 photograph of malarial transfusion from one patient to a neurosyphilitic patient.
Dr. Wagner-Jauregg is third from the right.

Around the time when Wagner-Jauregg was developing pyrotherapy, Sigmund Freud was developing psychoanalysis and reshaping psychiatry. Lieberman applauds Freud’s many contributions to psychiatry and neuroscience, but also admits that he made several mistakes. Critics, including Lieberman himself, disagree with Freud’s assertion that all human decisions are at least somewhat fueled by underlying sexual urges (44). Freud also drew a number of strange conclusions including that “a girl’s natural sexual development drives her to want a penis of her own” (Shrinks 56). Despite these errors, Freud was most notably the first to propose the revolutionary idea of unconscious thought (42). He also created the three-fold model of the human psyche (the id, ego, and superego), which continues to be among the most influential analytic models (Shrinks 41, 42). All of Freud’s theorizing culminated in the psychiatric practice of psychoanalysis, during which a therapist coaxes patients into understanding things hidden away in their unconscious minds, thus alleviating their mental illnesses (53). While many of us may have preconceived notions of Freud as “a self-important domineering phony, or a sex-obsessed shrink,” Lieberman presents him as a “tragic visionary far ahead of his time” that was “simultaneously psychiatry’s greatest hero and its most calamitous rogue” (39). Shrinks attempts to contextualize these stereotypes surrounding Freud and help skeptics understand his contributions, thereby fighting the stigma surrounding psychiatry.

Despite the advancements made by Freud, psychiatry still had a long way to go before it could be truly appreciated as a medical specialty. While psychoanalytic theory allowed for more effective treatment of some patients, it implied that every patient’s unconscious conflicts were unique and “could not be neatly packed into diagnostic boxes” (96). Thus, people began complaining of psychiatry’s erratic and unreliable diagnoses. This led to the beginning of the antipsychiatry movement as people tried to fill in the gaps in psychiatry’s understanding of mental illness with their own ideas while also asserting that physicians were not needed to treat mental disorders (115). The American Psychiatric Association addressed the matter of diagnostic inconsistency by publishing the third edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) in 1979, which essentially served as a reference detailing what specific psychiatric diagnosis corresponded to a particular set of symptoms exhibited by the patient.

Another accusation of the antipsychiatry movement was that mental illnesses were “fictions invented by psychiatry to justify charging patients for unscientific therapies of unknown effectiveness” (Shrinks 109). This idea, which originated in 1961 with Thomas Szasz’s book entitled The Myth of Mental Illness, still survives today. In the 21st century, however, researchers have found countless correlations between phenomena in the brain and certain mental disorders. For instance, researchers at the MRC Clinical Sciences Centre in London used neuroimaging to find that schizophrenic patients have high immune cell activity in the brain (Bloomfield).

While studies like these bring credibility and legitimize more treatments, FDA-approved psychopharmaceuticals continue to receive criticism. For example, a controversial study conducted in 2008 by Irving Kirsch supposedly showed “that most (if not all) of the benefits [of antidepressant drugs] are due to the placebo effect” (Kirsch). Since the publication of this study there have been countless rebuttals, including one by Hans-Jürgen Möller and Konstantinos Fountoulakis, who concluded that “the Kirsch et al.’s meta-analysis suffered from important flaws in the calculations; reporting of the results was selective and conclusions unjustified and overemphasized” (Fountoulakis). The antipsychiatry movement lives on but is weakening as psychiatry continues to establish itself as a legitimate medical science.

While the effectiveness of certain modern psychiatric drugs may be subject to debate, there is no doubt that great potential lies in the ability of drugs to alter the mind. To illustrate this point, Lieberman includes an interesting personal anecdote about his experience with LSD. After trying it in the 60s, Lieberman “marveled at the fact that such an incredibly minute amount of a chemical… could so profoundly affect [his] perceptions and emotions” (Shrinks 192). With the effects of LSD in mind, it shouldn’t seem unreasonable to think that scientists have been able to devise drugs that reduce hallucinations as opposed to inducing them. As the understanding of how the mind interacts with pharmaceuticals improves, researchers will be able to create more viable treatments for mental illnesses, earning psychiatry an even more affirmed place amongst the medical specialties.

Lieberman goes on to conclude Shrinks on a markedly positive note, citing several instances in which society and popular culture have become more accepting of mental illness, as well as a number of promising lines of research that will push the science behind psychiatry even further. Lieberman notes that “though we live in a time of unprecedented tolerance… mental illness – an involuntary medical condition that affects one out of four people – is still regarded as a mark of shame” (295). Addressing psychiatry’s stigma is no longer a matter of defending the scientific integrity of the specialty. The problem now is that “the public does not believe that psychiatry has truly advanced” (Shrinks 298). Lieberman’s fascinating account of the specialty’s history, however, is a step in the right direction. Shrinks is worth reading, not only for entertainment, but also as a testimony to something of far-reaching significance—that society can trust contemporary psychiatry to help the mentally-ill population.

Input your search keywords and press Enter.

mens enhancement supplements sildenafil 20mg tablets pills for dick growth famous chinese sex pills in us daily male enhancement supplement beyond the blue pill over the counter penis enhancement male enhancement for 26 year old xtra innings male enhancement pills best male over 40 enhancement duromax male enhancement pills online drugstore uk night man male enhancement pills i take red pill hugh hefner and male enhancement pills red dragon male enhancement pill 2x male enhancement primal force supplements encore hard male enhancement reviews what are best male enhancement pills natural supplements for sex drive otc ed pills zynga how enlarge my penis sex pills from sex shop does the blue pill work walgreens weight loss pills that work top online pills penis enlargement before and after 2020 pills or creams whats better for ed best otc energy pill boron supplements for ed you wanna buy penis enlargemnt pills super strong supplements ginseng penis enlargement erection pills in australia sustain male enhancement volume dick results types of penile enlargement surgery male enhancement pills what they look like best male enhancement techniques best supplement male enhancement boy gets penis enlargement libido booster contraception fix penis enlargement turkey neck huge penis enlargement projax penis pills 48 12 v blue pill chewing gum sex enhancement amazon royal supplements king kong sexual enhancement vmax review ed pills can you buy pills online horny goat weed drug interactions male enhancement pill has opposite effect herbal enhancers stiff rock male enhancement pills review over the counter energy pills can male enhancement pills cause urethritis androgel penis enlargement

zero vape pod ipv5 vape extreme vape cool vape coil builds liquid vape pen twister vape pen rx250 vape vape factor weed vape tanks vta vaping how to use a vape pen for wax laisimo vape instructions how many people in the us vape 510 vape tanks aces vape diy vape juice kit amazon eagle vape pen instructions exotic vape juice new york vaping sigelei 150 ecig darth vapor vape addict juices isopropanol vapor pressure v8 baby m2 how to know what coil your ecig needs vape cheap box mod ecig and impact on health liquid strength high quality ecig brands smok tfv8 big baby replacement glass aqua vape juice ingredients g2 vaporizer pen sour patch kid vape juice logic vaping e cigarette philippines price peach ring vape juice e cigarette shops manchester most expensive vape vaping cbd oil dangerous vapor sales online lipoid pneumonia vaping coconut oil best temp to vape weed at kangertech mods crown vape unique box mods pen vape charger box mod vape reviews ultra portable vape smok 4 battery mod waterproof vape mods smok skyhook rdta box 220w kit slim vape pen smok verification most popular e liquid how long does voopoo pod last red suorin air voopoo just drag with genechip vaping wholesale uk

weight loss pills doctor oz eastern medicine for weight loss ashley graham weight loss diet average weight loss on south beach diet pill for weight loss are the keto premium diet pills for real and safe lipoderm weight loss pills weight loss pill on dr oz show sibutramine weight loss pills how good are keto diet pills weight loss pills and supplements cardio diet weight loss ingreidient in keto diet sippleme t pills weight loss pills target keto diet side dish recipes weight loss supplements you can buy at walmart pork recipes for keto diet paleo diet sample meal plan for weight loss complete keto diet for beginners recipes weight loss drugs approved in canada fiber supplements to lose weight potato diet to lose weight green tea lose weight diet la 3 weight loss pills free paleo diet plan for weight loss ambislim weight loss pills ovo lacto vegetarian weight loss diet weight loss pills blake shelton best diet for weight loss women 40 years old pills to lose weight and build muscle free best weight loss pills science diet senior weight loss dog food weight loss pills in target healthy weight loss supplements keto advanced weight loss pills uk reviews celebrity weight loss diet plans most effective weight loss pills nz 50 cent weight loss diet side effects of keto advanced weight loss pills best weight loss diet for 50 year old woman weight loss pills in a month how much weight loss on low carb diet exercise diet for weight loss best diet crossfit weight loss indian diet dinner for weight loss what is the top rated weight loss pill weight loss fruit and vegetable diet ketone diet plan weight loss diet for office workers extreme diet for weight loss diabetic vegan weight loss diabetic diet plan quick weight loss protein supplements how many weight loss diet low carb diets lose weight eat carbs 1 day a week best fad diet for quick weight loss pre diabetic diet to lose weight pills to help you lose weight walmart white label weight loss pills

cbd oils scientific evidence for cbd oil cbd joints best pizza perth cbd can you take too much cbd good cbd brands cbd tinnitus cbd oil insomnia forum revive cbd oil z natural cbd cbd for glaucoma ga nutraceuticals cbd oil cbd gifts can cbd oil trigger migraines north carolina cbd koi cbd amazon cannabinoids cbd juul cbd cartridge is cbd legal in minnesota 2020 cannabis oil dosage for pain cbd oil and joint pain cbd dose for depression cbd oil to smoke restaurant sydney cbd lunch cbd vs prescription drugs cbd and grapefruit cbd essential oil doterra cbd lollipops terpenes vs cbd flight centre perth cbd vasayo cbd cost cbd coffee near me is cbd oil regulated by the fda ecs cbd oil prof whytes cbd oil cbd lube oil brisbane cbd flood cbd oil laws in indiana azuca cbd accommodation in melbourne cbd green helix cbd cbd oil stores in madison wi uses and benefits of cbd oil cbd laws in wisconsin cbd snake oil or real cbd and coumadin can you buy cbd oil in illinois cbd oil prices near me regalabs organic cbd oil ingredients cbd oil and fatigue can i overdose on cbd oil cbd oil for tetanus how much cbd is in 2500mg hemp oil make your own cbd tincture best place to get cbd oil near me nectar bee cbd oil tincture 100 ml cbd oil mgs does cbd oil show in a drug test