Developing American Attitudes on Mental Health and Violence | October Editor’s Choice

EC-October2018

By Zelda Blair | Senior Editor

Six years ago in December, twenty children and six adults were killed in a mass shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Connecticut. That spring, Emily R. Lebowitz wrote an article for Medical Dialogue Review addressing the national issue of inadequate delivery of mental health-care that was raised by the untreated mental illnesses believed to afflict the perpetrator of the Newtown murder-suicide (Lebowitz). In the five and a half years since her article was printed, American gun violence has only increased. More mass shootings in schools, movie theaters, churches, a music festival, and a nightclub are only a few instances among many; and in fact, this is not even the most deadly form of gun violence in the US. According to a recent analysis by Vox, the overwhelming majority of gun-related deaths are individual suicides (Lopez and Sukumar). Mass shootings receive the most media attention, but by the numbers, this is out of proportion to their actual impact.

 

Regardless of the disproportionate amounts of media attention these forms of death receive, mental illness is typically considered to be equally relevant for both. Suicide victims and mass murderers often suffer from similar mental diagnoses such as various forms of depression, anxiety, schizophrenia, autism spectrum disorders, PTSD, or comorbidities. They often share similar undiagnosed symptoms or abnormal behaviors such as paranoia, delusions, or social isolation; and may have been similarly exposed to environmental stressors such as developmental trauma or other social factors (Metzl and MacLeish, Swanson et al). The assumption most often made in media coverage of mass shootings or suicides is that mental illness has a causal relationship to the violent actions of the killer or suicide victim. In fact, this is not well established. Medical understanding of mental illness is still too limited to assume that suicide or other violent behavior can be directly causally attributed to it (Walkup and Rubin). One recent review assessed the substance of the connections made between mental illness and mass shootings, and the authors point out that attributing violent behavior to one mental diagnosis or another is a dangerous oversimplification of a complex phenomenon (Metzl and MacLeish). The majority of people diagnosed with the mental illnesses the media commonly associates with suicides and mass murders are not and never will be violent (Swanson et al). Assuming a causal relationship between these illnesses and violent behavior, aside from being bad science, will unjustly worsen the already heavy social stigma that they carry.

 

The desire to determine a cause is natural in the aftermath of horrific and quite abnormal acts of violence, but making mental illness into a scapegoat is too simple. It is tempting to attribute violence to disease, something unnatural and isolated which will be eradicated as soon as a cure can be found; but this has some serious implications. According to Metzl and MacLeish, “this framework—and its implicit promise of mental health solutions to ostensibly mental health problems—creates an untenable situation in which mental health practitioners increasingly become the persons most empowered to make decisions about gun ownership and most liable for failures to predict gun violence” (Metzl and MacLeish). While the correlations of mental illness with violence certainly merit investigation, exclusive attention to this one dimension is not the right way to approach a complex problem and may obscure the roles of other important factors.

 

Gun violence is equally related to socio-cultural factors, which are less easily ‘diagnosed and treated’ than mental illness. There is no expectation of a biomedical solution to problems like poverty and racial prejudice that result from being on the wrong side of the capitalist system. “Notions of mental illness that emerge in relation to mass shootings frequently reflect larger cultural issues that become obscured when mass shootings come to stand in for all gun crime and when ‘mentally ill’ ceases to be a medical designation and becomes a sign of violent threat” (Metzl and MacLeish). Even if a causal relationship between mental illness and violence exists, social determinants of health demonstrate that mental illness is often caused by early trauma and even genetics can be mediated by early environment (Kirkbride et al). For these reasons mental illness disproportionately affects the poor and systemically disadvantaged, suggesting that social factors are central to addressing mental illness as well as solving the problem of gun violence no matter how it is framed.

 

The problems of the poor are rarely given central importance in our society, despite the fact that they affect the majority of us in forms less violently dramatic than mass shootings. When a medicalized understanding of mental illness divorced from socio-economic realities is taken to be the primary cause of gun violence, then “public, legal, and medical discourses move ever-farther away from talking broadly and productively about the social, structural, and, indeed, psychological implications of gun violence in the United States” (Metzl and MacLeish). This presents a possible reason for the lack of success in understanding and preventing gun violence by the current strategies based exclusively on mental health models without consideration of important socio-cultural factors.

 

The attention mental illness receives in the context of gun violence does present an opportunity to address current problems of stigma and lack of access to care, as Lebowitz argues in her 2013 article; but it would seem that these goals will not be best achieved in the context of gun violence publicity. There has been little change in national attitudes on mental illness and access to mental health-care in the nearly six years since the Newtown shooting, despite continued links made in the media between gun violence and mental illness. “Anxieties about insanity and gun violence are also imbued with oft-unspoken anxieties about race, politics, and the unequal distribution of violence in US society” (Metzl and MacLeish). Perhaps addressing these cultural anxieties is the best way to achieve our dual goals of ending gun violence and improving attitudes and access in mental health-care. America’s deep social wounds will continue to cause pain until we find ways to heal them.

 

Since the Sandy Hook school shooting, some of the victims’ families have chosen to take action by initiating lawsuits against the gun manufacturers that produced the military-grade weapons used by the shooter. After some unfavorable decisions, their cases are being appealed (New York Times). By addressing the socio-economic sources of gun violence, these families are working to protect others from what they have experienced. Responding to the problem in this dimension challenges the established forces of inequality and injustice that underlie so much of the violence and illness of our country. Furthermore, it offers a perspective on the overextension of measurement as a tool for problem solving. The approach to understanding violence and mental health in terms of measurements of molecules in a de-contextualized body may be inadequate for comprehending and healing this depth of pain: the pain that causes someone to kill, and the further pain that their actions cause others, may be of a qualitative nature that will elude forms of measurement. It is well past time to try new approaches in the effort to identify and heal the sources of American gun violence, beginning with the systemic wounds that we can no longer pretend to ignore.

 

References:

Kirkbride JB, Jones PB, Ulrich S, Coid J. Social deprivation, inequality and the neighborhood level incidence of psychotic syndromes in East London. Schizophrenia Bulletin. 2014;40(1):169-180.

Lebowitz, E. The future of mental health in post-Newtown America. NYU Medical Dialogue Review. 2013;7(2):42-46.

Lopez G, Sukumar K. After Sandy Hook we said never again. Vox.com. https://www.vox.com/a/mass-shootings-america-sandy-hook-gun-violence. Updated October 3, 2018. Accessed October 26, 2018.

Metzl JM, MacLeish KT. Mental illness, mass shootings and the politics of American firearms. Am J Public Health. 2015;105(2):240-249.

Rojas R, Hussey K. Newtown is ‘still so raw’, five years after Sandy Hook shooting. New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/12/13/nyregion/newtown-sandy-hook-five-year-anniversary.html. Published December 13, 2017. Accessed October 26, 2018.

Swanson JW, McGinty EE, Fazel S, Mays, VM. Mental illness and reduction of gun violence and suicide: bringing epidemiologic research to policy. Annals of Epidemiology. 2015;25(5):366-376.

Tal E. Measurement in science. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/measurement-science/. Published 2015. Accessed October 29, 2018.

Walkup JT, Rubin DH. Social withdrawal and violence–Newtown, Connecticut. New England Journal of Medicine. 2013;368:399-401.

 

Input your search keywords and press Enter.

what is in extenze male enhancement ed pills levitra ed pills over the counter the bull ed pills noxatril male enhancement extenze pills with alcohol red hot pill male enhancement sex pills over the couter best male enhancement pills in dubai where can you buy penis growth pills at xanogen male enhancement for sale gnc mood enhancer dillons male enhancement premium power male enhancement fire ant male enhancement reviews max size male enhancement reviews the male enhancement center prices doctor prescribe sex pills magnum penis enlargement rings viper x male enhancement v white pill ebay blue sex pills go blue pill orignal sex pills wholesale in usa pills to help erectile dysfunction best male enhancement pill blue little pill best sex male pills best ginsing ed pills v 09 19 pill allergy medicine comparison enlarged prostate low libido male enhancement products reves binaural beats for male enhancement lion bakala penis enlargement excersize how to increase libido while on pills best meal penis pills honey pills natural foods for sex enhancement reviews on male enhancement top 20 sex enhancement pills pills to take after sex to prevent uti estrogen balancing supplements silver bullets pills low testerone drugs male enhancer max 11 garlic supplement ladies viagra tablets name in india vigrx plus drug test male enhancement message board volume pills male enhancement increase semen chinese all natural sex pills any side effects from store bought ed pills what are the best gas station sex pills male enhancement pills needing a prescription are male enhancement pills effective

discover cbd cbd oil tincture dosage calculator how does cbd oil make you feel cbd oil epilepsy what does smoking cbd feel like real time pain relief cbd aromaland cbd where to buy cbd oil in salt lake city best cbd hemp flower cbd auckland cbd oil massage near me does cbd oil show on a ua cbd balance cbd store portland thrive cbd san diego cbd oil and alcohol cbd lotion reviews how to make cbd isolate cbd oil mail order your cbd store emmaus cbd pain relief cream near me can children on cbd oil reproduce cbd oil for autism and epilepsy houston news cbd oil cbd vs keppra cbd review cbd dental care new orleans canna hemp cbd oil does cbd oil help with constipation cbd sciences max cbd dose natures ultra cbd review north dakota cbd law cbd oil with ibuprofen cbd cough drops does cbd impair driving ancient oil cbd free sample of cbd oil university in sydney cbd cbd ear drops virtual golf sydney cbd sports physio sydney cbd apartment in sydney cbd for rent cbd l kaufen cbd oil uses for pain glaucoma and cbd what kind of cbd oil should i use how do you make cbd isolate what cbd oil for pain cbd for liver disease cbd oil what is it legal for in ct loyal leaf cbd cbd oil legal in states cbd icy hot can cannabis oil cure copd will cbd test positive for thc

quick liquid diet weight loss salad and fruit diet weight loss the best weight loss pill for women new weight loss drug belviq blue weight loss pill prescription weight loss diet pills speed supplements pills to take while on keto diet indian veg dinner diet for weight loss keto diet small recipes what category of drugs are weight loss pills some free simple recipes for the keto dietl weight loss pills liporexall whats a good diet to lose weight fast extreame obese weight loss pills will a liquid diet help me lose weight diets for quick weight loss and muscle gain how to lose weight vegetarian diet no diet and exercise weight loss drink weight loss diabetes drug can you take lose weight pills while pregnant ge weight loss diet keto diet pills kate middleton dinner for weight loss diet pills that make u lose weight carrie underwood weight loss supplement what is the best fast weight loss diet weight loss pills canada non prescription can you lose weight by just dieting how long for weight loss on keto diet keto burn diet pills side effects asian weight loss pills scam best weight loss pills in europe weight loss help pills weight loss medicines in pakistan extreme weight loss pills caffine free best weight loss pills recommended by doctors most effective perscription weight loss pills watermelon diet and weight loss box of weight loss pills michigan weight loss pill called garcinia cambogia best weight loss pills in france lose weight with vegan diet guaranteed weight loss pills at gnc weight loss metabolic syndrome diet la weight loss diet recipe total fit keto diet pills review subway soup weight loss diet reds weight loss pills weight loss diet indian purchase weight loss diet evidence based diet for weight loss tammy roman nv weight loss pills best diet for weight loss in college keto advanced weight loss pills side effects best diet supplements for fast weight loss in men do caffeine pills help with weight loss

vape mod explodes what is a nord best vape ever v2pro series 3x vape pen payless vape shop la vape e liquid wow vape is no nicotine vaping bad njoy vape review 7 11 e cig sigelei vape 200w halo ecig coupon on the go juno vape near me buy vapor pens online cloud vape pens voopoo drag an valarian vape shop cincinnati e cigarette eleve amazon vapes vaping and e cigarettes vapor gypsy diamond mist e cigarette instructions black rock vapor are vape pens bad ecig pens ecig 45415 thc vape juice recipe what is the default coil that comes with the uwell crown tank vape juice high nicotine 250 watt box mod my undead girlfriend vape juice g priv 2 luxe smok osub one blueberry pomegranate vape juice 100watt vape uwell caliburn moisture e liquid nicotine concentrate smoke vape pen 22 smok g priv 2 update firmware ecig clubhouse limited edition uwell crown ecig express black friday uwell rafale ni200 coil wattage best ecig tank best gauge for uwell crown rba low pressure sodium vapor lamp voopoo demon 24mm rda uwell nunchaku tank voopoo drag 2 platinum maat tank toxic metals found in e cigarette vapor voopoo black drag case rx200 mod for sale voopoo rex just says check atomizer 5280 vapor voopoo drag battery door for sale vape pen cigarette